© R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Dr. Rick Timbs President/CEO R. G. Timbs, Inc. April 2026 MSRB Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board SEC Emblem R. G. Timbs, Inc. is Registered with: School District: Finance Strategic Plans Leadership Educational Development Long Range Financial Analysis: Preliminary Findings and Implications Data Driven Fiscal Planning Fort Plain Central School Logo Return to Home Canajoharie Central School District HFM BOCES, Johnstown, NY © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Purpose of the Long-Range Financial Analysis (LRFA) study: The Canajoharie CSD & Fort Plain CSD: Feasibility Study for the Purpose of Centralization, Final Report – January 2025 conducted by Leadership Solutions Advisers, LLC included the following: Q. Are both districts' budgets sustainable under current trends and predictions? A. Both Canajoharie and Fort Plain districts are fiscally stable at present. However, projections indicate that expenditures are growing at a faster rate than revenues, leading to the likelihood of budget deficits as early as the next fiscal year. Without adjustments—such as reducing costs, increasing revenues, or leveraging efficiencies from a merger—both districts may face challenges in maintaining balanced budgets in the future. The feasibility study suggests that merging the districts offers a viable path to enhance sustainability through resource sharing and operational efficiencies, reducing the financial risks each district currently faces. p.9. Q. Will property taxes increase after the merger? A. Financial projections indicate that a merger would result in stable property taxes in the short term due to state Reorganization Incentive Aid. The design of this aid is to offset costs for a period of 14 years. Long-term impacts depend on the merged district's financial planning. It is fair to conclude that overtime, merger or no merger, state fiscal policies, and historical trends clearly indicate that taxes will likely increase on an annual basis to ensure continuity of services. It is also important to note that the annual district vote authorizes a tax levy amount. The district does not assign individual homeowner property tax—just the total levy amount. Individual property tax amounts are based on local assessments. p.9. © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 To address these issues R. G. Timbs, Inc., was contacted by the District Superintendent of the Herkimer Fulton Montgomery BOCES to inquire about an additional in-depth study to provide more information about the financial preparation of each district over the next five years. To address this analysis R. G. Timbs, Inc. conducted a further review of each district’s current financial condition and a realistic probable future including with and without reorganization and the financial accouterments that come with it. This process is called Long-Range Financial Analysis (LRFA). The use of more a more thorough analysis of current and immediate future financial strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats a “post reorganization” financial plan was crafted as a reasonable example of the degree to which the financial largess provided by reorganization could enhance the opportunities for a newly reorganized district and provide a means to contain, ameliorate or eliminate potential financial weaknesses and threats. This process would further test a particular financial finding as articulated in the Feasibility study: Financial Sustainability Both districts maintain strong fiscal positions, supported by balanced budgets and reserves. However, rising expenditures highlight the need for strategic financial planning. The merger would unlock significant financial incentives, including state reorganization aid, which could fund program enhancements, tax stabilization, and capital improvements. By streamlining operations and reducing redundancies, the merged district would create a sustainable framework to support long-term growth. p.4. Thus, a reasonable LRFA would be conducted as if no reorganization would occur and could be contrasted with an LRFA as if a reorganization did occur. This report is not intended to duplicate the work of the original study but rather to enhance and further articulate a select number of findings and implications it contained. Purpose: In concert with the Hamilton Fulton and Montgomery BOCES, develop a Long-Range Financial Analysis and Plan for Canajoharie CSD and the Fort Plain CSD post reorganization including budgeting guidelines and strategies, reserves, fund balances, debt service issues for capital projects and transportation, calculation of probable revenue and expense streams, surpluses in revenues and expenditures, the inclusion of Reorganization Operating and Building aids and related issues. Expectations for Deliverables: With the cooperation and assistance of each district and the Hamilton Fulton Montgomery BOCES, R. G. Timbs, Inc. will provide the following: 1. A long-range financial analysis of a probable financial plan that includes:1. Budgeting guidelines and strategies 2. Reserves and fund balances 3. Debt service issues for capital projects and buses 4. Calculation of surpluses in revenues and expenditure 5. Tax Cap Implications 6. The inclusion of Reorganization Operating Aid 7. The inclusion of Reorganization Building Aid 8. Recommendations for the creation and maintenance of the reorganized districts ongoing financial health. 9. Presentation(s) to the parties affected. Proposal Limitations: This proposal is limited to the creation of a Long-Range Budget Document with Analysis as outlined above. Additionally, this proposal is limited to work with the Superintendents, District Business Offices, and Board of Education of Canajoharie CSD and Fort Plain CSD, and necessary officers of the Hamilton Fulton Montgomery BOCES, to ascertain and define a Long-Range Financial Analysis of the probable financial trajectory post reorganization. © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Data sets examined and research mechanisms included: 1. District Submissions to SED of the Form ST-3 with Revenue and Expense Variances 2. State Education Department (NYSED) website aid calculations as they are updated 3. Current Capital Projects Data: Bonds, Bond Anticipation Notes Use; Existing Debt Service Schedules 4. Foundation Aid history and potential changes 5. Other Related State Aid –Expense Driven- including but not limited to-Excess Cost Aids, BOCES and Transportation Aid 6. Types of Reserves used by the District 7. The degree to which the district possesses or uses Capital Reserves 8. Fund Balance History 9. Examination of Tax Cap Calculations 10. Potential Financial Events that have implications for the District’s Tax Cap calculations 12. Statewide Reports of the Comptroller of the State of New York (OSC) as they relate to the district 13. Use of Funds (Appropriated Fund Balances, Unappropriated Fund Balances) 14. Projected Teachers Retirement System Rates and Employees Retirement System Rates 15. Projected Contractual Obligations of the district 16. Analysis of the impact on district budgets due to potential the loss of PILOT agreement payments 17. The District’s Tax Levy history 18. The District’s Revenue and Expenditure Variance history 19. Recent or Pending Statute, Regulation or Decisions of the Commissioner that might have implications for the District’s Finances 20. Evidence of District-wide Long-Range Financial Planning 21. Interviews with the School Business Officials and Superintendents © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Q. Are both districts' budgets sustainable under current trends and predictions? A. Both Canajoharie and Fort Plain districts are fiscally stable at present. However, projections indicate that expenditures are growing at a faster rate than revenues, leading to the likelihood of budget deficits as early as the next fiscal year. Without adjustments—such as reducing costs, increasing revenues, or leveraging efficiencies from a merger—both districts may face challenges in maintaining balanced budgets in the future. The feasibility study suggests that merging the districts offers a viable path to enhance sustainability through resource sharing and operational efficiencies, reducing the financial risks each district currently faces. p.9. Canajoharie CSD & Fort Plain CSD Feasibility Study for the Purpose of Centralization Purpose of this portion of the study: To test the assumptions noted on page nine of the Canajoharie CSD and the Fort Plain CSD Feasibility Study or the Purpose of Centralization as presented to the Joint Boards of Education on January 16, 2025. The study will use a process known as long-range financial analysis (LRFA) as provided by R. G. Timbs, Inc, registered municipal advisor. R. G. Timbs, Inc. works exclusively with school districts across New York State. Presented to the Joint Boards of Education on January 16, 2025 © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Are both districts' budgets sustainable under current trends and predictions? 1. Both Canajoharie and Fort Plain districts are fiscally stable at present. 2. However, projections indicate that expenditures are growing at a faster rate than revenues, leading to the likelihood of budget deficits as early as the next fiscal year. 3. Without adjustments—such as reducing costs, increasing revenues, or leveraging efficiencies from a merger—both districts may face challenges in maintaining balanced budgets in the future. The first analysis was subdivided into three specific topics from the original study: © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Are both districts' budgets sustainable under current trends and predictions? 1. Both Canajoharie and Fort Plain districts are fiscally stable at present. True • Both districts have functioning budgets and adequate to robust programs in various areas. • Each district is prepared to offer a continuance of service and steady finances into the 2026-27 school year pending voter approvals by respective residents. • Each district has created a budget for 2026-27 relying on a modest increase in taxes. • Each district is in anticipated receipt of continued state support for such items as building aid, transportation aid, BOCES aid and aid categories related to the education of special needs students among other aid categories. • Each district has built a budget that will rely on, to some extent, the use of fund balances and reserves as needed, should actual expenses outpace predicted revenues. • Should either district need to use designated appropriated fund balances or reserves they have sufficient funds in the short-term. • Each district has proper amounts budgeted for all contractual obligations, current state mandates and anticipated operational functions. © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Demographics and State Aid Save-Harmless/Hold-Harmless (Related to the original study) How does a district qualify for hold harmless, and what does that mean? A. "Hold harmless" applies when a district’s calculated Foundation Aid (based on state formulas) is lower than the previous year's allocation. To qualify, a district must demonstrate that its aid calculation based on the state formula would decrease compared to the prior year's aid amount due to changes in enrollment, district wealth, or other formula metrics. The "hold harmless" provision ensures the district receives at least the previous year's aid amount, stabilizing funding and enabling the district to maintain operations without immediate cuts. It provides essential financial predictability for districts navigating fluctuating variables that impact state aid. p.8. 1% to 0%???% State Aid © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 The eventual specific impact of the District’s Save-Harmless Status is unknown. However, even if there is a 1% or even 2% increase annual increase in Foundation Aid, compared to more previous years this will result in diminished revenue capacity to counter projected cost escalations in expense trajectories. 1% to 0%???% State Aid © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 The eventual specific impact of the District’s Save-Harmless Status is unknown. However, even if there is a 1% or even 2% increase annual increase in Foundation Aid, compared to more previous years this will result in diminished revenue capacity to counter projected cost escalations in expense trajectories. © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Demographics and State Aid The historic loss of weighted student counts and the most recent loss is the main factor for the diminishment for eligibility for more Foundation Aid despite a significant recognition of a variety of poverty measures within the district that would demonstrate a high needs population and that the district is below average wealth based on income and property values compared to the rest of the state. These wealth factors do contribute to the maintenance of elevated reimbursement ratios for building, transportation, high cost, and BOCES aid categories. Further, the implications of the annual growth (13.3%) of the Expected Local Contribution portion of the Foundation Aid formula tends to negate any insinuation that more aid should be provided. Additionally, the Tax Base Growth Factor portion of the Tax Cap calculation would lead to the similar conclusion; that the district has at least recent increased property tax capacity. © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Demographics and State Aid The historic loss of weighted student counts despite their most recent increase is the main factor for the diminishment for eligibility for more Foundation Aid. This is despite a significant recognition of a variety of poverty measures within the district that would demonstrate a high needs population and that the district is below average wealth based on income and property values compared to the rest of the state. These latter wealth factors do contribute to the maintenance of elevated reimbursement ratios for building, transportation, high cost, and BOCES aid categories. Further, the implications of the annual growth (10.4%) of the Expected Local Contribution portion of the Foundation Aid formula tends to negate any insinuation that more aid should be provided. Additionally, the Tax Base Growth Factor portion of the Tax Cap calculation of 1.0052 would lead to a similar conclusion; that the district has at least recent increased property tax capacity. © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Are both districts' budgets sustainable under current trends and predictions? 1. Both Canajoharie and Fort Plain districts are fiscally stable at present. Caveats: The revenue structure of each district continues to erode significantly in the face of escalating costs: • State support for each district is waning and has been for a last the last three years. • State Aid is a major source of revenue for both districts providing 65% for Canajoharie and 70% for Fort Plain of the total. • Of the total state aid amount Foundation Aid represents 71.1% for Canajoharie and 67.2% for Fort Plain. • Taxes make up 32.4% for Canajoharie and 26.4% for Fort Plain of total revenues. • Both districts are “save-harmless” (also called “hold harmless”) and the Foundation Aid formula calculates that neither district is due for any increase at all (although the Executive budget suggests a meager 1% increase for each district.). The Foundation Aid formula upon examination, is currently providing more aid for each district than the formula without special legislation would allow. The amount currently provided to the district beyond the formula are Canajoharie: $423,216; Fort Plain: $389,180. • Further the continued loss of enrollment and increased tax bases of each district negatively affects expense driven and supplemental aid categories. • Costs of salaries, health insurance, pensions, bus and related transportation expenses, and the cost of utilities and maintenance of infrastructure and the necessary accouterments of the educational program continue to accelerate beyond the rates of increases slated for both Foundation Aid and taxes over the next five years and beyond. © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 This reserve plan represents forward-thinking long-range planning by the district The amounts above 4% will be assumed to be as part of reserves the purposes of this study © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 This reserve plan represents forward-thinking long-range planning by the district Assumptions Revenues: Tax Increase Annually State Aid Save Harmless small increase in Foundation Aid for 1 year Variable BOCES and Public Excess Cost Aids Variable Building Aid follows Debt Service Schedule* Federal Aid (Medicaid) remains Stable Expenditures: Follow contractual Obligations No notable changes in staff patterns Stable ERS and TRS increased costs* Inflationary Costs Escalate Expenditures Rapidly © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Tax Levy % Increases are an example only and do not represent official Tax Cap calculation 2028 and forward © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Change in Fund Balances Will this plan basically keep the district financially afloat to 2031... No CASHFLOW © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Canajoharie CSD © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Canajoharie CSD © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Note Growing use of FB to Balance Budget Note Growing Gap Unbalanced Budget -$5,292,392 Canajoharie CSD © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Let’s talk about the Tax Cap… Canajoharie CSD Tax Cap Calculations... As if the district stayed at the cap Canajoharie CSD Tax Cap Calculations... Actual Tax Cap History © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Canajoharie CSD Tax Cap Calculations... Actual Tax Cap History (With No Carry Over) © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Assumptions Revenues: Tax Increase Annually State Aid Save Harmless small increase in Foundation Aid for 1 year Variable BOCES and Public Excess Cost Aids Variable Building Aid follows Debt Service Schedule* Federal Aid (Medicaid) remains Stable Expenditures: Follow contractual Obligations No notable changes in staff patterns Stable ERS and TRS increased costs* Inflationary Costs Escalate Expenditures Rapidly © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Tax Levy % Increases are an example only and do not represent official Tax Cap calculation 2028 and forward © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Change in Fund Balances Will this plan basically keep you financially afloat to 2031... Barely CASHFLOW © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Fort Plain CSD © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Fort Plain CSD © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Note Growing use of FB to Balance Budget Note Growing Gap Unbalanced Budget -$4,160,500 Fort Plain CSD © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Let’s talk about the Tax Cap… Fort Plain CSD Tax Cap Calculations... As if the district stayed at the cap Fort Plain CSD Tax Cap Calculations... Actual Tax Cap History © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Fort Plain CSD Tax Cap Calculations... Actual Tax Cap History (With No Carry Over) © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Are both districts' budgets sustainable under current trends and predictions? 2. However, projections indicate that expenditures are growing at a faster rate than revenues, leading to the likelihood of budget deficits as early as the next fiscal year. Partially True • A district cannot continuously spend more than their revenue for very long. Such a strategy will drain cashflow, fund balances and reserves. • The lack of continuous and substantial increased state support will restrict the revenue trajectories of both districts as largely absent major tax increases to provide the revenue needed to continue the staffing needed for the educational programs as costs escalate and compound significantly over the next few years. • Recent tax increases have not been calibrated to recent increased costs and each district has resorted to trimming anticipated budget calculations whereby on occasion, fund balances have been used in the past to cover budget shortfalls. It is anticipated that this practice will continue and moreover, reserves themselves will be tapped to keep the annual budget of each district in some form of balance, on paper. • Reserves created and cultured over the years for specific and meaningful purposes will be used to sustain each district until the money simply runs out. • The cashflow of each district will be absorbed by the costs of ever-increasing budgets when revenues prove insufficient and then each district will begin to borrow to sustain staff and programs. This will further exacerbate the financial condition of each district as debt worthiness will begin to drop as evidenced by decreased bond ratings and the addition to the budget of the cost of annual borrowing through temporary bond anticipation notes that incur issuance costs and interest charges. This will add to each district's financial demise. © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Are both districts' budgets sustainable under current trends and predictions? 2. However, projections indicate that expenditures are growing at a faster rate than revenues, leading to the likelihood of budget deficits as early as the next fiscal year. True • It is clear based on a specific long range financial analysis and plan created for each district that salaries and benefits alone will out pace all ordinary revenues easily over the next five years. • Absent a major infusion of revenues over the next few years each district will be obliged to cut a significant number of staff and programs to stay financially afloat, thus dismantling the educational mission of each district. • Despite the best efforts of each district:• the historic minimum increases in Foundation Aid and tax increases that averaged less than 2% in each district for years will eventually serve to produce a deleterious revenue shortfall, • coupled with state-imposed restrictions on the creation and use of reserves and accumulation of fund balances, this has stymied their ability to significantly provide for more robust reserves or even a “rainy day” structure that would enable the them to weather financial shortfalls in annual and ongoing revenue targets particularly when compared to ever-increasing expense escalations. © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Are both districts' budgets sustainable under current trends and predictions? 3. Without adjustments—such as reducing costs, increasing revenues, or leveraging efficiencies from a merger both districts may face challenges in maintaining balanced budgets in the future. True All budgets are a balance of revenues to expenses. The lower the revenue picture the more strain on expenses; and visa versa. After a long-range financial analysis of the Canajoharie CSD budget and projects for the next five years, to be financially solvent in the year 2030-31: • The district would need a ~15% tax increase in the next year (2026-27) for instance, unless they were to cut a financial equivalent of expenses (programs and staff through reductions in force, attrition and program loss) over the next school year. • Alternatively, if there was to be the studied only 2.5% raise in taxes, an equivalent of a cut in expenses (programs and staff through reductions in force, attrition and program loss) over the next school year of ~$850,000 would be needed. After a long-range financial analysis of the Fort Plain CSD budget and projects for the next five years, to be financially solvent in the year 2032-33: • The district would need a ~12% tax increase in the next year (2026-27) for instance, unless they were to cut a financial equivalent of expenses (programs and staff through reductions in force, attrition and program loss) over the next school year. • Alternatively, if there was to be the studied only 1.25% raise in taxes an equivalent of a cut in expenses (programs and staff through reductions in force, attrition and program loss) over the next school year of ~$600,000 would be needed. © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Purpose of this portion of the study: Q. Will property taxes increase after the merger? A. Financial projections indicate that a merger would result in stable property taxes in the short term due to state Reorganization Incentive Aid. The design of this aid is to offset costs for a period of 14 years. Long-term impacts depend on the merged district's financial planning. It is fair to conclude that overtime, merger or no merger, state fiscal policies, and historical trends clearly indicate that taxes will likely increase on an annual basis to ensure continuity of services. It is also important to note that the annual district vote authorizes a tax levy amount. The district does not assign individual homeowner property tax—just the total levy amount. Individual property tax amounts are based on local assessments. p.9. At some point taxes cannot be replaced completely with the Reorganization Operating Incentive Aid • It will be easier to stabilize the tax levy in the first five years than in the last five years. • Much of this is dependent on the Board of Education (BOE) elected by the residents of the newly merged district • If the BOE plans carefully and distributes the proceeds of the merger aid to address taxes, program expenses and reserves to support ongoing needs of a fully functioning district some amount of tax relief is possible. © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Important Note: Incentive Aid amounts provided are a projection, and all actual Aid apportioned to a new school district following a reorganization is subject to final calculation by the State Aid Unit once all variables are fixed for the coming year. p. 109 © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 With the merger of two or more school district all the aid categories are simply added together as was done above. Additionally, the influx of a significant amount of Reorganization Incentive Aid begins in the first year of the merger. The state provides Reorganization Incentive Aid as a financial bridge to cover initial expenses and adjustments during the merger process. This incentive reduces strain due to finances, allowing the districts to transition smoothly while making long-term improvements. From the state’s perspective, merged districts operate more efficiently and maximize taxpayer dollars, benefiting students and the broader community. p.8. Combined State Aid © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Reserves would be built and expensed in ways that advantage the district financially. Buying equipment, vehicles, and buses with cash would be available (no borrowing costs, no interest costs, no leasing costs) over a prolonged period. Capital reserves would be created and expended over time based on a series on long-term (15 years or more) purchase plans and a master capital improvement plan Assumptions Revenues: Example Only: No LevyIncrease in First Five years State Aid Save Harmless small increase in Foundation Aid for 1 year Example: The Inclusion of Reorganization Incentive Operating Aid in 2026-27 Variable BOCES and Public Excess Cost Aids Variable Building Aid follows Debt Service Schedule* Federal Aid (Medicaid) remains Stable Expenditures: Follow contractual Obligations No notable changes in staff patterns Stable ERS and TRS increased costs* Inflationary Costs Escalate Expenditures Rapidly © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Tax Levy % Increases are an example only and do not represent a recommendation nor a successful strategy. © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Change in Fund Balances Will this plan basically keep you financially afloat to 2031... Easily CASHFLOW © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 This portion of this study tests a particular financial finding as articulated in the original Feasibility study: Financial Sustainability Both districts maintain strong fiscal positions, supported by balanced budgets and reserves. However, rising expenditures highlight the need for strategic financial planning. The merger would unlock significant financial incentives, including state reorganization aid, which could fund program enhancements, tax stabilization, and capital improvements. By streamlining operations and reducing redundancies, the merged district would create a sustainable framework to support long-term growth. p.4. True The district should be easily able to address taxes, program expenses and long-range reserve planning through the thoughtful use of the following: • Reorganization Operating Incentive Aid of $83,966,290 over 14 years • Reorganization Incentive Building Aid ($ TBD) • The prudent creation, maintenance and use of reserves, using Capital Reserves in particular • The proactive practice of program management through the creation of measurable goals for all programs accompanied by continuous evaluation and the elimination of barriers to success and adjustment of abandonment when needed. • The continuous examination of staffing aimed at great efficiencies and effectiveness over time, that includes the strategies the evaluation of need coupled with attrition and breakage as a mode of financial accountability. © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Canajoharie CSD 93.7% 92.4% 95% Building Aid Ratios Additional notes for clarification based on NYSED Review: . Reorganization Incentive Building Aid: New Buildings / Adding New Space • When adding new space, the highest district building aid ratio prior to reorganizing is increased by 30%, up to a maximum Aid Ratio of 95%. The Office of Facilities Planning calculates a Maximum Cost Allowance for Building Aid, based on projected enrollment after reorganizing, for all new construction projects. Costs above the MCA are not eligible for Building Aid. • New capital projects must start within the first 10 years after a merger for enhanced Building Aid ratio to be applied. . Enhanced ratio is not permanent. • ***Note also that the highest ratio is increased by 30% of that ratio—so the formula is: (Ratio x 0.3) + (Ratio) = Enhanced Ratio, where Enhanced Ratio cannot be greater than 95%. . Reorganization Incentive Building Aid: Renovating Existing Facilities and Existing Capital Debt • If the reorganized District renovates current buildings without adding new space, approved projects are aided at the enhanced Building Aid Ratio. • Maximum Cost Allowance for existing buildings will not be reduced if no new space is added during renovation. • Additionally, NYSED will adjust Building Aid payments for existing capital debt to match the higher of the two previous districts’ building aid ratios (Aid Ratio is not enhanced). p. 110. Reorganization Incentive Building Aid For school districts that reorganize, Incentive Building Aid is 30 percent of the Building Aid otherwise paid on an approved building project. Incentive Building Aid is made available for new facilities capital projects started within 10 years of the effective date of reorganization. In no case, however, may the sum of regular Building Aid and Incentive Building Aid exceed 95 percent of approved building expenditures in these areas or 98 percent for districts eligible for the high-needs Supplemental Building Aid Ratio. © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Capital Construction: The previous page data from the original study reveals the following: • That the Building aid Ratio for the first 10 years of the merger will be 95% (95% of eligible capital construction costs will be covered by Building Aid). The work must be eligible for building aid and within the Maximum Cost Allowances as of the of Commissioner Approval Date (CAD) for the project. • The Maximum Cost Allowance (Building Aid Units portion) for each building in the current district will remain unchanged as long as the capital project work includes no additions to building(s) (within the current building footprint) or new buildings. • “The Office of Facilities Planning calculates a Maximum Cost Allowance for Building Aid, based on projected enrollment after reorganizing, for all new construction projects. Costs above the MCA are not eligible for Building Aid.” p. 110. This will no doubt drastically reduce the amount of eligible work that could be supported by state aid as enrollment at that time will be considerably lower than the enrollment used to calculate the current Maximum Cost Allowance. • “This incentive calculation would generate an additional $222,321 of building aid on existing debt payments through 2042.” p. 103. Other Considerations: • Due to time constraints on the Enhanced Reorganization Building Aid, the Current Building Condition Surveys for each district (Canajoharie’s reveals the need for capital work of ~$35,267,040, and Fort Plain by contrast ~$37,949,245:• A newly elected Board of Education would need to develop a Capital Improvement Master Plan complete with project scope by building, cost targets based on future estimates and timeline to match the district reserves, finances, and make every effort to secure the maximum amount of state support for the first 10 years and beyond. © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Building Conditions Survey All school districts in New York State are required to conduct a Building Conditions Survey (BCS) every five years. The BCS identifies current issues in the buildings and forecasts that may occur in these buildings. Not every item that is identified in the BCS needs to be addressed immediately. The review of each district’s most recent BCS serves as a basis for potential capital improvements that will need to be considered and prioritized moving forward. p. 86. Most Current BCS data sets with Incidental Cost Assumptions • New capital projects must start within the first 10 years after a merger for enhanced Building Aid ratio to be applied. . Enhanced ratio is not permanent. p. 110 Every newly merged district would review and prioritize the BCS for each building and determine what if anything should be included in future capital projects. Subsequent work would commence with the district’s financial advisor, architect and construction manager. © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 • The Maximum Cost Allowances (MCA) renew after five years after Commissioner Approval Date of current and previous capital projects (per building) and become rejoined into a recalculated MCA. • Significant amounts of MCA will become available over the next few years providing a considerable amount of aid eligible structure for future capital projects with the allowed amount to maximize the use of Enhanced Building Reorganization Aid. • The ability to use these specific aid funds for capital improvement are at their maximum benefit within only the first 10 years of merger. Maximum Cost Allowance calculation provided by the district from their financial advisor, Fiscal Advisors & Marketing, Inc. for the purposes of this study. © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Maximum Cost Allowance calculation provided by the district from their financial advisor, Bernard P. Donegan, Inc. for the purposes of this study. • The Maximum Cost Allowances (MCA) renew after five years after Commissioner Approval Date of current and previous capital projects (per building) and become rejoined into a recalculated MCA. • Significant amounts of MCA will become available over the next few years providing a considerable amount of aid eligible structure for future capital projects with the allowed amount to maximize the use of Enhanced Building Reorganization Aid. • The ability to use these specific aid funds for capital improvement are at their maximum benefit within only the first 10 years of merger. © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 General Considerations on Capital Construction projects revolve around the following: • Need based on program, building conditions, and community input • State Support• Building Aid Ratio • Bond Percent• Aid Eligibility • By project scope • By Building • By Maximum Cost Allowance • Coordination with State Education Department (NYSED); Office of Facilities Planning • District Contribution (Reserves or Cash)• Affordability • Timing• Vote Date and public notifications, public information meetings • Commissioner's Approval Date • Filings to SED • Finance plan and Borrowing • Final Cost Report • Community Support With sufficient financial planning, capital project goals can be met within the 10-year window that would maximize state support to 95% of aid eligible costs. Additionally, provision can me make for additional capital projects beyond that time as needed to maintain the district’s infrastructure and other future needs that would involve capital construction © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Q. In your knowledge of merged schools, could you describe how (do) schools function after the extra money runs out? Have they encountered problems? A. After the incentive aid expires, districts that plan well often transition successfully. These schools typically use the incentive period to invest in lasting programs, restructure operations for efficiency and build financial reserves. However, districts that do not adequately prepare may encounter challenges such as budget deficits, program cuts, or increased reliance on reserves. Much like any organization, if there is effective leadership, there is a much better chance for long-term success. p.8. True • The most successful strategy is to plan well and plan well ahead. • A downside to 15 years of significant unrestricted revenue enhancements to any school district would be hard to determine. Generations of students and the school community would benefit particularly compared to the identified alternative based on the current financial trajectory for each district. • If the districts were to merge right now, students not yet old enough to be in a Pre Kindergarten program would no doubt benefit through an entire educational experience easily through 12th grade. • Aside from family, the school district is the greatest contributor to the life of a student not only while in school but afterwards as well. • We cannot tell if a merger will produce the same careful stewards of school district funds over the next 15, 20, 25 or even 30 years, as it has done so far. However, it is financially clear that current and approaching circumstances point to the need for significantly greater influx of financial resources or there will be an inevitable diminishment of what are now robust programs for the children of each current district. CONSIDERATIONS Caveats and Limitations • The budget process is always difficult due to the number of assumptions (Extrapolate cost estimates). Update estimates as possible for both Revenues and Expenses. (No one can actually calculate exact unanticipated costs or revenues such as loss of staff due to resignations, marriages, a car accidents, getting sick etc., to cover leaves, new students with special needs costs, interest earnings, Foundation Aid and other items... These are the best reasonable estimates that can be made.) • “School District” inflation Costs escalations of supplies, materials and equipment is a concern. • Immediately, reevaluate purchases and staff need. Examine the possibility of attrition and breakage, where possible but monitor certain labor scarcity issues. Cost escalations must be seriously decreased. • Scrutinize escalations of Long-term Expenditures that include but are not limited to: Health Insurance, Salaries, Pension Costs, Transportation Costs that must be addressed in the financial plan and the limitations on Revenues must be examined. • Develop a Long-Range thoughtful plan to prepare for possible State Fiscal Funding Cliff in the future and because school districts cannot count on increases in some state aid categories that are sustainable to create a more positive financial plan. What does the future hold? © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 RECOMMENDATIONS Strategically and Operationally Examine Long Range Budget Implications… 1. The Tax Cap at the 2, 3 or even 4% level will no longer be sufficient when faced with double digit expense increases in large expenses portions of the budget, future amounts of Foundation Aid increases in question, and the draw down of reserves (even when wisely used). • The timing of capital construction and/or bus purchases and the financial strategy with them must take into consideration significant cost escalations in other areas soin the future these reserves may be needed for other purposes. 2. The district has consideration regarding revenues and expenses• There is always a “willingness to pay more taxes” conundrum. • The district cannot spend more than its revenues. Examine the need for staff through out the school district as greater efficiencies are needed. The goal would be to significantly decrease EXPENSES and quickly. • The district must continue to “right size” the relationship between expenses and revenues based on diminished enrollments and trend data, course offerings, class sizes, student demographics and other metrics. Be mindful of “student needs” demographics as there are more students with special needs. 3. Reductions in Fund Balances within the budget instead of reductions of costs will strain the district’s cashflow and ability to financially function rather quickly. 4. Realistically, the ability to meaningfully build “reserves” is gone. Absent the significant sums of previously available extraordinary funds such as Federal Grants (CRRSA and ARPA) the district has lost fund balance opportunities, and the ability to create and maintain Reserves. © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Strategically and Operationally Examine Long Range Budget Implications… 5. The costs associated with the Zero-Emissions bus mandate are currently unreachable -waivers are needed. 6. The distance between anticipated revenues and expenses will grow significantly over the next few years. The distance between anticipated revenues and expenditures becomes more magnified as expenses escalate faster than revenues. • At the current overall budget trajectory, salaries and benefits will overwhelm the district's finances vs. almost all potential perceived “ordinary” Revenue gains. • Failure to act immediately and over the next few years will make it more difficult to sustain the district’s financial potency. • The larger the tax increase the smaller the cuts in expenses; the smaller the tax increase the larger the cut in expenses. (Expense to Revenue Equivalency) 7. The district needs to revisit all possible options to examine cost savings and implement financial triage.• State Aid: Foundation Aid- the district is currently slated for 1% Increase in Foundation Aid in 2026-27; any future increases in Foundation Aid are unknown due to enrollment declines and district demographic changes. Currently, Expense driven aid continues as in current law but are only partial reimbursements. 5. Immediate significant cost reductions must or tax increases must produce a financial yield that is significant enough to sustain the district long-term, as cashflow is also maintained 6. Caution....Monitor the Tax Cap… note growing use of Appropriated Fund Balance and be aware of Super Majority Tax Levy Limit financial and political implications. © R. G. Timbs, Inc. 2026 Other options short of merger: Tuitioning Students Dependent on: • The plan? • The number of students, the ability of the receiving district to absorb “some number” of students without cost. • Transportation of students? • Access to BOCES programs? • Special education? • The amount of tuition costs? • Impact on the sending district? • Will it generate enough funds to stabilize each district’s finances? Regionalization Determine: • What would be shared? • Cost vs. Benefit • Who benefits? • Are there any downsides? • Will it generate enough funds to stabilize each district’s finances? What does the future hold? That’s up to the voters. Long Range Financial Analysis: Preliminary Findings and ImplicationsData Driven Fiscal Planning Return to Home Canajoharie Central School District HFM BOCES, Johnstown, NY